|
|
|
date: Sat, 31 Oct 2009 11:54:56 +0000,
group: uk.sport.golf
back
Bunkers
A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the bunker
to improve the surface before he plays.
Is this OK
Densi
date: Sat, 31 Oct 2009 11:54:56 +0000
author: Denis Cary
|
Re: Bunkers
Denis Cary wrote:
> A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the bunker
> to improve the surface before he plays.
> Is this OK
>
> Densi
Yes.
There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
not lie in the bunker.
cheers
david
date: Sun, 01 Nov 2009 07:14:29 +1100
author: david s-a
|
Re: Bunkers
On Oct 31, 3:14 pm, david s-a wrote:
> Denis Cary wrote:
> > A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the bunker
> > to improve the surface before he plays.
> > Is this OK
>
> > Densi
>
> Yes.
>
> There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
> not lie in the bunker.
>
> cheers
> david
......or any similar bunker.
date: Sun, 1 Nov 2009 03:42:56 -0800 (PST)
author: JohnT
|
What about dec. 13-2/28 ?
13-2/28 Smoothing Irregularities in Bunker Situated Between Ball and Hole
Q. There is a bunker between A's ball and the hole. Before playing, A
smoothes footprints and other irregularities in the bunker on his line of
play. Was A in breach of Rule 13-2?
A. Yes, such action would improve the line of play, contrary to Rule 13-2.
"JohnT" wrote in message
news:bf3e8616-412e-44ea-8c6d-f026ac1c8223@v25g2000yqk.googlegroups.com...
On Oct 31, 3:14 pm, david s-a wrote:
> Denis Cary wrote:
> > A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the bunker
> > to improve the surface before he plays.
> > Is this OK
>
> > Densi
>
> Yes.
>
> There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
> not lie in the bunker.
>
> cheers
> david
......or any similar bunker.
date: Mon, 2 Nov 2009 10:55:48 +0100
author: j.valentin
|
Re: What about dec. 13-2/28 ?
j.valentin wrote:
> 13-2/28 Smoothing Irregularities in Bunker Situated Between Ball and Hole
>
> Q. There is a bunker between A's ball and the hole. Before playing, A
> smoothes footprints and other irregularities in the bunker on his line of
> play. Was A in breach of Rule 13-2?
>
> A. Yes, such action would improve the line of play, contrary to Rule 13-2.
>
>
>
>
>
> "JohnT" wrote in message
> news:bf3e8616-412e-44ea-8c6d-f026ac1c8223@v25g2000yqk.googlegroups.com...
> On Oct 31, 3:14 pm, david s-a wrote:
>> Denis Cary wrote:
>>> A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the bunker
>>> to improve the surface before he plays.
>>> Is this OK
>>> Densi
>> Yes.
>>
>> There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
>> not lie in the bunker.
>>
>> cheers
>> david
>
> ......or any similar bunker.
>
>
>
Ok...we were not aware, from the original post, as to whether the bunker
in question was actually on the line of play. "Expecting his shot may
well go into a bunker" is not that specific. (I always expect my shots
to go into bunkers, line of play or not, and they usually do!!) There
are a whole bunch of decisions on "improving the line of play" in this
context. and if this IS the case then you are right.....and the Decision
is relevant.
cheers
david
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 07:40:55 +1100
author: david s-a
|
Re: What about dec. 13-2/28 ?
david s-a wrote:
> j.valentin wrote:
>> 13-2/28 Smoothing Irregularities in Bunker Situated Between Ball and
>> Hole
>>
>> Q. There is a bunker between A's ball and the hole. Before playing, A
>> smoothes footprints and other irregularities in the bunker on his line
>> of play. Was A in breach of Rule 13-2?
>>
>> A. Yes, such action would improve the line of play, contrary to Rule
>> 13-2.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> "JohnT" wrote in message
>> news:bf3e8616-412e-44ea-8c6d-f026ac1c8223@v25g2000yqk.googlegroups.com...
>> On Oct 31, 3:14 pm, david s-a wrote:
>>> Denis Cary wrote:
>>>> A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the
>>>> bunker
>>>> to improve the surface before he plays.
>>>> Is this OK
>>>> Densi
>>> Yes.
>>>
>>> There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
>>> not lie in the bunker.
>>>
>>> cheers
>>> david
>>
>> ......or any similar bunker.
>>
>>
> Ok...we were not aware, from the original post, as to whether the bunker
> in question was actually on the line of play. "Expecting his shot may
> well go into a bunker" is not that specific. (I always expect my shots
> to go into bunkers, line of play or not, and they usually do!!) There
> are a whole bunch of decisions on "improving the line of play" in this
> context. and if this IS the case then you are right.....and the Decision
> is relevant.
>
> cheers
> david
So, exactly what situation did you have in mind
then when you read the post? What else can,
'...There is a bunker between A's ball and the
hole...' possibly mean?
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 21:03:14 +0000
author: Ruth
|
Re: What about dec. 13-2/28 ?
Ruth wrote:
> david s-a wrote:
>> j.valentin wrote:
>>> 13-2/28 Smoothing Irregularities in Bunker Situated Between Ball and
>>> Hole
>>>
>>> Q. There is a bunker between A's ball and the hole. Before playing, A
>>> smoothes footprints and other irregularities in the bunker on his
>>> line of play. Was A in breach of Rule 13-2?
>>>
>>> A. Yes, such action would improve the line of play, contrary to Rule
>>> 13-2.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> "JohnT" wrote in message
>>> news:bf3e8616-412e-44ea-8c6d-f026ac1c8223@v25g2000yqk.googlegroups.com...
>>>
>>> On Oct 31, 3:14 pm, david s-a wrote:
>>>> Denis Cary wrote:
>>>>> A player, expecting his shot may well go into a bunker, rakes the
>>>>> bunker
>>>>> to improve the surface before he plays.
>>>>> Is this OK
>>>>> Densi
>>>> Yes.
>>>>
>>>> There is no restriction under Rule 13-2 or Rule 13-4 if his ball does
>>>> not lie in the bunker.
>>>>
>>>> cheers
>>>> david
>>>
>>> ......or any similar bunker.
>>>
>>>
>> Ok...we were not aware, from the original post, as to whether the
>> bunker in question was actually on the line of play. "Expecting his
>> shot may well go into a bunker" is not that specific. (I always expect
>> my shots to go into bunkers, line of play or not, and they usually
>> do!!) There are a whole bunch of decisions on "improving the line of
>> play" in this context. and if this IS the case then you are
>> right.....and the Decision is relevant.
>>
>> cheers
>> david
>
>
> So, exactly what situation did you have in mind then when you read the
> post? What else can, '...There is a bunker between A's ball and the
> hole...' possibly mean?
Just about anything...
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 12:27:24 +1100
author: david s-a
|
|
|
