|
|
|
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 12:13:35 +0000,
group: uk.adverts.computer
back
Which Laptop
I am looking to buy a laptop for a child but I don't know much about
them. I am currently looking at this one, could someone who knows give
me their views / suggest an alternative I don't want to spend more than
this.
Lenovo 3000 G550 £390
http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Lenovo_3000_G550_Laptop_NTDE6UK/version.asp?PID=1372
Thanks.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 12:13:35 +0000
author: Raggy
|
Re: Which Laptop
Raggy wrote:
> I am looking to buy a laptop for a child but I don't know much about
> them. I am currently looking at this one, could someone who knows give
> me their views / suggest an alternative I don't want to spend more than
> this.
>
> Lenovo 3000 G550 £390
>
> http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Lenovo_3000_G550_Laptop_NTDE6UK/version.asp?PID=1372
Thats your average 15.6" notebook good make though, the latest notebooks
are built with ULV processors (ultra low voltage) and come with 6 or 8
cell batteries giving 5 - 8 hour battery life at the expense of some cpu
performance. This sounds like what netbooks have been doing this last
year or so but these ULV machines are not netbooks they are vastly more
powerfull esp the dual core variants.
A child might not need 5 hour battery life so a normal non-ulv machine
will probably suffice and you will struggle to find a dual core ULV
machine for £ 400 inc VAT, the Acer Aspire Timeline 1810tz I ordered
last week is £ 449.99 at Amazon slightly over your budget.
So it really depends what you need, do you want to follow current trends
and go ULV or stick to a tradional laptop.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 12:38:54 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Nick Le Lievre wrote:
>
> Thats your average 15.6" notebook good make though, the latest notebooks
> are built with ULV processors (ultra low voltage) and come with 6 or 8
> cell batteries giving 5 - 8 hour battery life at the expense of some cpu
> performance. This sounds like what netbooks have been doing this last
> year or so but these ULV machines are not netbooks they are vastly more
> powerfull esp the dual core variants.
>
> A child might not need 5 hour battery life so a normal non-ulv machine
> will probably suffice and you will struggle to find a dual core ULV
> machine for £ 400 inc VAT, the Acer Aspire Timeline 1810tz I ordered
> last week is £ 449.99 at Amazon slightly over your budget.
>
> So it really depends what you need, do you want to follow current trends
> and go ULV or stick to a tradional laptop.
Oh and by the way most ULV machines do not have DVD Drives, this is in
order to reduce weight and make the machine as slim as possible and it
also conserves battery life. The exception to this rule is Dells range
of ULV laptops in particular the 13 and 15" Inspiron z models.
The 11.6" Timeline 1810tz I am awaiting delivery of does not have a DVD
drive, which for me is not a great loss as I never watch DVDs on my
laptop and I do have an external drive to connect for those rare times
when I need to install something from DVD.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 13:09:35 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 12:13:35 +0000, Raggy wrote:
>I am looking to buy a laptop for a child but I don't know much about
>them. I am currently looking at this one, could someone who knows give
>me their views / suggest an alternative I don't want to spend more than
>this.
>
>Lenovo 3000 G550 £390
>
>http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Lenovo_3000_G550_Laptop_NTDE6UK/version.asp?PID=1372
>
>Thanks.
Probably you're spending too much if it is a child and not a teenager on the web
/at college.
We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our grand-
daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are going to
get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
Peter
--
Peter A Forbes
Prepair Ltd, Rushden, UK
peterforbes@prepair.co.uk
http://www.prepair.co.uk
http://www.prepair.eu
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 14:03:46 +0000
author: Peter A Forbes
|
Re: Which Laptop
In article , Peter A Forbes
says...
> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our grand-
> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are going to
> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>
I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
rugged ones for their kids.
--
Conor
www.notebooks-r-us.co.uk
I'm not prejudiced. I hate everybody equally.
date: Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000
author: Conor
|
Re: Which Laptop
On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000, Conor wrote:
>In article , Peter A Forbes
>says...
>
>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our grand-
>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are going to
>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>
>I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>rugged ones for their kids.
They are very good machines IMO.
Peter
--
Peter A Forbes
Prepair Ltd, Rushden, UK
peterforbes@prepair.co.uk
http://www.prepair.co.uk
http://www.prepair.eu
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:02:17 +0000
author: Peter A Forbes
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Conor" wrote in message
news:MPG.2558fdd6b330cbd39898cf@news.eternal-september.org...
> In article , Peter A Forbes
> says...
>
>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our
>> grand-
>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are
>> going to
>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>
> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
> rugged ones for their kids.
>
>
>
> --
I got 2 T43's left on E bay out of 20+ I had.
Item : 380166404762
& Item: 380172066509
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:08:44 GMT
author: Raj Kundra raj@REM0VE THISkundracomputers.co.uk
|
Re: Which Laptop
Conor wrote:
> In article , Peter A Forbes
> says...
>
>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our grand-
>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are going to
>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>
> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
> rugged ones for their kids.
I suppose it depends on whether the OP would consider 2nd hand or not as
these machines that you mention are a good couple of years old and out
of date in specification that may be a factor for a teenager who wants
the latest/greatest also depends how much money OP has to spend and he
seems to have about £ 390 which will buy a decent brand new machine with
Windows 7. If its a child of 5 years of age I do not suppose it matters.
When I sold my Toshiba A200GE-26P earlier in the year for £ 300 the
buyer wanted something that was in immaculate as new condition it was a
present for his daughter, it was only a year old so the specification
was up to date and I restored it to as new condition with the recovery
DVD, it was boxed and everything it looked new I paid £ 432 for it a
year earlier and got £ 50 cashback from Toshiba.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:10:04 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Peter A Forbes wrote:
> On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000, Conor wrote:
>
>> In article , Peter A Forbes
>> says...
>>
>>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our grand-
>>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are going to
>>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>>
>> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>> rugged ones for their kids.
>
> They are very good machines IMO.
Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:12:49 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Nick Le Lievre wrote:
> Conor wrote:
>> In article , Peter A
>> Forbes says...
>>
>>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for
>>> our grand-
>>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are
>>> going to
>>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>>
>> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>> rugged ones for their kids.
>
> I suppose it depends on whether the OP would consider 2nd hand or not as
> these machines that you mention are a good couple of years old and out
> of date in specification that may be a factor for a teenager who wants
> the latest/greatest also depends how much money OP has to spend and he
> seems to have about £ 390 which will buy a decent brand new machine with
> Windows 7. If its a child of 5 years of age I do not suppose it matters.
>
> When I sold my Toshiba A200GE-26P earlier in the year for £ 300 the
> buyer wanted something that was in immaculate as new condition it was a
> present for his daughter, it was only a year old so the specification
> was up to date and I restored it to as new condition with the recovery
> DVD, it was boxed and everything it looked new I paid £ 432 for it a
> year earlier and got £ 50 cashback from Toshiba.
Needs to be new she's 12 so it matters big time, what about Acer?
http://direct.tesco.com/q/R.206-7486.aspx
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:19:02 +0000
author: Raggy
|
Re: Which Laptop
Raggy wrote:
>
> Needs to be new she's 12 so it matters big time, what about Acer?
>
Disposable?
--
Adrian C
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:28:58 +0000
author: Adrian C lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Raggy wrote:
>
> Needs to be new she's 12 so it matters big time, what about Acer?
>
> http://direct.tesco.com/q/R.206-7486.aspx
You cannot really beat that on price, in my opinion Acer are fine I had
one and had no problems with it, I do not really buy based on make as I
will buy anything if its the right spec/price although I avoided Dell
this time round and they were not really any cheaper in fact I got 1GB
more RAM for £ 5 extra with the Acer.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:40:08 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Adrian C wrote:
> Raggy wrote:
>
>>
>> Needs to be new she's 12 so it matters big time, what about Acer?
>>
>
> Disposable?
>
Should really quality that - how long do you think she'll be using this
machine. How is/was she with attitude to care of things expensive. Has
she grasped the value of money? Is this laptop going to have studeous
use or just facebook plaything. Is a decent keyboard more important than
a webcam?
Acer models are good for a few things, it's just the bargain basement
models will be a bit of a longevity risk. And if you are paying for a
high spec CPU or graphics chipset (something for a gamer like Nick),
something else has to give. There are some horrible keyboards out there.
I'd go with Dell, HP, Lenovo (my choice) or Toshiba. I'd also get on top
of all the educational discounts out there for machine and software.
--
Adrian C
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:41:53 +0000
author: Adrian C lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Adrian C wrote:
>
> Acer models are good for a few things, it's just the bargain basement
> models will be a bit of a longevity risk. And if you are paying for a
> high spec CPU or graphics chipset (something for a gamer like Nick),
> something else has to give. There are some horrible keyboards out there.
>
Yeah the Acer I owned 2 years ago was not cheap it was over £ 500 and
had a low performance discrete graphics card and a Core 2 Duo CPU back
when Core 2 Duos in notebooks were expensive.
I am not really a gamer when it comes to notebooks as you often have to
pay a fortune to get something reasonable and nowadays I much more
concerned about battery life, the A200GE-26P I had earlier this year had
a Radeon Mobility 2600HD which was fairly decent but I never played
games on it so a bit of a waste for time for me.
The Acer Timeline 1810tz I am getting is also not a bargain basement
model so should be fairly good quality wise, I did not choose Dell
because they crank out machines at a rate of knots and they are rather
bland.
Toshiba have always been good although the A200GE-26P was a business
model so it did not have multimedia keys and was rather bland in
appearance but it did not bother me.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:50:02 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Nick Le Lievre" <nicklelievre@jerseymail.co.uk.invalid> wrote in message
news:hcmv2d$qto$1@aioe.org...
> The Acer Timeline 1810tz I am getting is also not a bargain basement model
> so should be fairly good quality wise, I did not choose Dell because they
> crank out machines at a rate of knots and they are rather bland.
I'd never recommend a Dell for this reason. Dell build quality in general
has gone right down the pan since they started competing on a budget, how
many Dell models have NOT suffered some sort of design fault (on quite a few
models, multiple design faults) that shows up after a couple of years. Like
anything you get what you pay for and Dell obviously opted for volume and
have been trading on the back of their previous good rep for build quality
for some time now (far too long). I am just wondering when the bubble is
going to burst for them.
date: Mon, 2 Nov 2009 16:02:11 -0000
author: Niel J Humphreys
|
Re: Which Laptop
Niel J Humphreys wrote:
>
> I'd never recommend a Dell for this reason. Dell build quality in general
> has gone right down the pan since they started competing on a budget, how
> many Dell models have NOT suffered some sort of design fault (on quite a few
> models, multiple design faults) that shows up after a couple of years. Like
> anything you get what you pay for and Dell obviously opted for volume and
> have been trading on the back of their previous good rep for build quality
> for some time now (far too long). I am just wondering when the bubble is
> going to burst for them.
It already has for me. Its just a shame so many others are still buying
from them based on past reputation.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 16:26:02 +0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
Niel J Humphreys wrote:
> I'd never recommend a Dell for this reason. Dell build quality in general
> has gone right down the pan since they started competing on a budget,
So avoid their budget models?
Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
But equally for your valid reasons run a mile away from the Dell Vostro
series on the desktop. Totally Horrid. :-(
*Then again (I'm a banana) take a look at reviews for Samsung's R519
featured recently on the Gadget Show (yes, I know.... that program is as
impartial as ...)
Argos has it for £349 at the moment. Hear good things about that one
even though it's got a basic spec compared with others.
--
Adrian C
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 18:14:36 +0000
author: Adrian C lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Adrian C" <email@here.invalid> wrote in message
news:7l8lscF3d15leU1@mid.individual.net...
> Niel J Humphreys wrote:
>> I'd never recommend a Dell for this reason. Dell build quality in general
>> has gone right down the pan since they started competing on a budget,
>
> So avoid their budget models?
It's not their budget models though (didn't say it was), their corporate
machines are riddled with design faults, hate to think about the standard of
their 'retail' models.
date: Mon, 2 Nov 2009 19:04:35 -0000
author: Niel J Humphreys
|
Re: Which Laptop
On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 19:04:35 -0000, Niel J Humphreys
wrote:
> "Adrian C" <email@here.invalid> wrote in message
> news:7l8lscF3d15leU1@mid.individual.net...
>> Niel J Humphreys wrote:
>>> I'd never recommend a Dell for this reason. Dell build quality in
>>> general
>>> has gone right down the pan since they started competing on a budget,
>>
>> So avoid their budget models?
>
> It's not their budget models though (didn't say it was), their corporate
> machines are riddled with design faults, hate to think about the
> standard of
> their 'retail' models.
>
>
I'm not so sure HP models are much better.
I've seen several in for repair with one or the other of these two common
faults:
1) No boot - just a beep sequence
Usually where the Northbridge has excessively overheated and has partially
desoldered itself from the mainboard.
New mainboard needed.
2)On board wireless adapted vanishes
(A re-install of the driver doesn't find it either.)
New mainboard or fit PC Card express Wlan card.
These faults are frequently seen on HP models having AMD cpu's
What's worse is the "over the pond" HP branch recognizes this as a problem
and has websites instructing customers how to invoke and use a warranty
extension to get these issues fixed. (Fear of a Class action lawsuit no
doubt)
In the UK if you get the fault after 1 year's up you're stuffed.
They will repair but at a cost which IMO not worthwhile.
After all if it's design fault and no fix is in place, then a repair will
most likely fail in the same way.
date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 21:19:45 -0000
author: (((°
|
Re: Which Laptop
Nick Le Lievre wrote:
> Peter A Forbes wrote:
>> On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000, Conor wrote:
>>
>>> In article , Peter A
>>> Forbes says...
>>>
>>>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for
>>>> our grand-
>>>> daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they are
>>>> going to
>>>> get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>>>
>>> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>>> rugged ones for their kids.
>>
>> They are very good machines IMO.
>
> Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
> give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
If they're just using it for web and email access then what difference
does it make? If the only requirements are cheap and rugged then the
fact that it's not cutting edge hardware is completely irrelevant.
--
[ste]
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 02:22:57 +0000
author: [ste parker]
|
Re: Re: Which Laptop
On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:12:49 +0000, Nick Le Lievre
<nicklelievre@jerseymail.co.uk.invalid> wrote:
>Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
>give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
Unless your 14year old is a techie whizz-kid, and used to having expensive
pressies, then it is pretty much irrelevent as long as it works and does the
job.
It's up to our grand daughter's parents to spend that kind of money if they want
to, and I know they wouldn't for the same reasons that we wouldn't. Kids have a
very short attention span, and this years presents are January's ebay sales.
Christmas is about giving, not how much you are spending.
Peter
--
Peter & Rita Forbes
Email: diesel@easynet.co.uk
http://www.oldengine.org/members/diesel
http://www.stationary-engine.co.uk
http://www.oldengine.co.uk
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 07:39:54 +0000
author: Peter A Forbes
|
Re: Which Laptop
Peter A Forbes wrote
>On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 15:12:49 +0000, Nick Le Lievre
><nicklelievre@jerseymail.co.uk.invalid> wrote:
>
>>Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
>>give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
>
>Unless your 14year old is a techie whizz-kid, and used to having expensive
>pressies, then it is pretty much irrelevent as long as it works and does the
>job.
>
>It's up to our grand daughter's parents to spend that kind of money if they want
>to, and I know they wouldn't for the same reasons that we wouldn't. Kids have a
>very short attention span, and this years presents are January's ebay sales.
>
>Christmas is about giving, not how much you are spending.
>
... and a laptop is for life, not just Christmas, you can tell 'em. ;-)
--
Roger Hunt
date: Tue, 3 Nov 2009 07:50:28 +0000
author: Roger Hunt
|
Re: Which Laptop
In article , Adrian C
<email@here.invalid> writes
>Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
>model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
>elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
>components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
quibbling about build quality is pointless.
To the OP: basic, cheap, disposable = Acer and other cheap brands, if
you want something that lasts buy a used Stinkpad or a Tosh.
--
(\__/)
(='.'=) Bunny says Windows 7 is Vi$ta reloaded.
(")_(") http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/windows_7.png
date: Tue, 3 Nov 2009 07:59:58 +0000
author: Mike Tomlinson
|
Re: Which Laptop
In article <KZuhyoE+L+7KFwLb@jasper.org.uk>, Mike Tomlinson says...
> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
Lenovo's corporate range are still built to the level they used to be.
Newest one I've sold is 3 months old.
But yes, many are rebadged Gericom et al. DSG's E-systems range are
rebadged Asus.
--
Conor
www.notebooks-r-us.co.uk
I'm not prejudiced. I hate everybody equally.
date: Tue, 3 Nov 2009 09:08:12 -0000
author: Conor
|
Re: Which Laptop
Mike Tomlinson wrote:
> In article , Adrian C
> <email@here.invalid> writes
>
>>Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
>>model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
>>elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
>>components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
>
> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
3 Factories in Taiwan to be exact - Quanta, Compal and Clevo. Usually the
better kit is Quanta and the cheapest Clevo but there are some from both
ends of the range from all 3 companies (Dell use both Quanta and Compal).
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 18:18:45 +0000
author: Nigel Feltham
|
Re: Which Laptop
Mike Tomlinson wrote:
> In article , Adrian C
> <email@here.invalid> writes
>
>>Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
>>model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
>>elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
>>components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
>
> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
Interesting article on who makes what laptops - curiously it appears that
Lenovo use the same maker as Dell and Acer.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2008/jun/27/didquantaorcompalmakeyour
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 18:20:26 +0000
author: Nigel Feltham
|
Re: Which Laptop
Nick Le Lievre wrote:
> Peter A Forbes wrote:
>> On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000, Conor wrote:
>>
>>> In article , Peter A Forbes
>>> says...
>>>
>>>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our
>>>> grand- daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if they
>>>> are going to get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>>>
>>> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>>> rugged ones for their kids.
>>
>> They are very good machines IMO.
>
> Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
> give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
Especially where the kid is likely to take the thing to school - would you
want the kid to get bullied for having last year's kit (or this year's
budget kit - any excuse to start trouble for some kids).
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 18:24:41 +0000
author: Nigel Feltham
|
Re: Which Laptop
In article , Nigel
Feltham says...
> Especially where the kid is likely to take the thing to school - would you
> want the kid to get bullied for having last year's kit (or this year's
> budget kit - any excuse to start trouble for some kids).
--
Conor
www.notebooks-r-us.co.uk
I'm not prejudiced. I hate everybody equally.
date: Tue, 3 Nov 2009 18:56:36 -0000
author: Conor
|
Re: Which Laptop
Peter A Forbes wrote:
> Christmas is about giving, not how much you are spending.
Yawn...
date: Tue, 03 Nov 2009 20:49:39 +0000
author: Ruth
|
Re: Which Laptop
On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 07:39:54 +0000
Peter A Forbes wrote:
> Christmas is about giving, not how much you are spending.
No it's not, it's about the ickle baby jeebus.
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 00:37:39 +0000
author: Rob Morley
|
Re: Which Laptop
On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 18:20:26 +0000, Nigel Feltham wrote:
> Mike Tomlinson wrote:
>
>> In article , Adrian C
>> <email@here.invalid> writes
>>
>>>Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
>>>model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
>>>elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
>>>components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
>>
>> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
>> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
>> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
>> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
>> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
>
> Interesting article on who makes what laptops - curiously it appears that
> Lenovo use the same maker as Dell and Acer.
>
> http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2008/jun/27/didquantaorcompalmakeyour
Which demonstrates that it's engineering and materials choices that
determine end quality. Assembly, subject to appropriate levels of control,
is just a formality, and junk is a successful outcome if that's what was
intended.
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 05:26:08 +0000
author: nog
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Nigel Feltham" wrote in message >>
>> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
>> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
>> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
>> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
>> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
>
> Interesting article on who makes what laptops - curiously it appears that
> Lenovo use the same maker as Dell and Acer.
>
> http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2008/jun/27/didquantaorcompalmakeyour
I recieved my new Acer Timeline 1810tz today and I am very impressed at the
battery life, just had it on since 14:25 its now 15:45 and its only gone
down to 80% which by my calculations means this baby can last 6.66 hours its
in power saver mode but still has enough grunt to playback Youtube SD videos
smoothly, have not tried HD in power save mode yet.
By comparison my old slow netbook the EEE PC 901 could last 4.5 hours in
power save mode and did not have enough grunt for even Youtube SD, this is a
fantastic machine only cost £ 391.30 ex VAT inc delivery from Amazon. By the
way I have tried Windows Live Mail for newsgroups and its improved a lot
since the version I tried under Vista, its basically the same as the old
Windows Mail.
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 15:52:41 -0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Nick Le Lievre" <nicklelievre@jerseymail.co.uk.invalid> wrote in message
news:hcs7st$crt$1@news.albasani.net...
> I recieved my new Acer Timeline 1810tz today and I am very impressed at
> the battery life, just had it on since 14:25 its now 15:45 and its only
> gone down to 80% which by my calculations means this baby can last 6.66
> hours its in power saver mode but still has enough grunt to playback
> Youtube SD videos smoothly, have not tried HD in power save mode yet.
>
> By comparison my old slow netbook the EEE PC 901 could last 4.5 hours in
> power save mode and did not have enough grunt for even Youtube SD, this is
> a fantastic machine only cost £ 391.30 ex VAT inc delivery from Amazon. By
> the way I have tried Windows Live Mail for newsgroups and its improved a
> lot since the version I tried under Vista, its basically the same as the
> old Windows Mail.
Here is a size comparison to a 15.4" Acer notebook of March 2008 vintage
http://yfrog.com/2mpict0501bj
Yes its not quite as small as an EEE PC 901 but its not a lot bigger either
and you have 6.5 hours battery life decent dual core CPU & corresponding
performance 3GB RAM 250GB HDD Windows 7, looking at the machine its amazing
how they have managed to fit a 2.5" drive in there its so thin. Its the best
notebook I have ever owned.
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 16:52:13 -0000
author: Nick Le Lievre lid
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Mike Tomlinson" wrote in message
news:KZuhyoE+L+7KFwLb@jasper.org.uk...
> In article , Adrian C
> <email@here.invalid> writes
>
>>Those would be fancy things alway below the spec and build of the Lenovo
>>model that started this thread. Dell's offered playmates for lowend junk
>>elsewhere. A real laptop with OS for £300 can't really be done with good
>>components, so it's all junk down there. Almost* Guaranteed.
>
> What no-one realises is that with the exception of Lenovo and Toshiba,
> who are trading by the skin of their teeth on their previous history of
> building decent machines, is that all laptops come from the exact same
> factory in Taiwan, regardless of whether they're Dells or Acers. So
> quibbling about build quality is pointless.
Do Hps also come from this factory?
--
Vista: the hd dvd player that thinks it's an operating system ©JC 2009
Windows 7: a faster dvd player
All men are islands
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 20:10:15 -0000
author: jasee
|
Re: Which Laptop
"Nigel Feltham" wrote in message
news:qtKdnVlSuPv06G3XnZ2dnUVZ8gxi4p2d@brightview.co.uk...
> Nick Le Lievre wrote:
>
>> Peter A Forbes wrote:
>>> On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 14:32:24 -0000, Conor wrote:
>>>
>>>> In article , Peter A Forbes
>>>> says...
>>>>
>>>>> We are in the process of sorting out a couple of IBM Thinkpads for our
>>>>> grand- daughters. At least we'll know without spending too much if
>>>>> they
>>>>> are going to get any use out of them, and can always upgrade later.
>>>>>
>>>> I've had a few enquiries for Thinkpad T42s for people wanting cheap
>>>> rugged ones for their kids.
>>>
>>> They are very good machines IMO.
>>
>> Good machines but old and obselete spec not something I would want to
>> give my 14 year old as a present to show how much I loved him.
>
> Especially where the kid is likely to take the thing to school - would you
> want the kid to get bullied for having last year's kit (or this year's
> budget kit - any excuse to start trouble for some kids).
I hope the above is sarcasm? I've seen parents totally ruin* their kids by
always giving them the latest kit: phones, game machines etc.
*One is 17, tagged and about to be sentenced for RWV, the other is 15, can't
be stopped xboxing day and night.
date: Wed, 4 Nov 2009 20:22:01 -0000
author: jasee
|
|
|